The Spider and the Shield·

Narrator

On August tenth, two thousand nineteen, the wealthiest sex offender in modern American history was found dead in a cell in lower Manhattan. There were eleven cameras in his unit. Only one was recording. The two guards assigned to him had spent the night shopping online for furniture.

By the time the federal investigation closed four years later, the conclusion was this: he had killed himself. And the only reason he was able to was that the institution holding him collapsed around him.

That is one ending of the Jeffrey Epstein story.

The film you're about to watch is about everything that happened before it. Every door that opened, every officer who looked away, every newsroom that killed the story, every prosecutor who signed off, every billionaire who kept calling.

Narrator

Jeffrey Edward Epstein was born in nineteen fifty-three in a triplex in Sea Gate, Brooklyn — the same building that once housed Joseph Heller's family. His father swept leaves for the Parks Department. He shared a bedroom with his brother.

Narrator

At Lafayette High School, the alma mater of Sandy Koufax, he was bullied. He was lumbering, with a five-o'clock shadow at twelve. A classmate would later remember him standing in the hall in ninth grade, hands at his sides, telling her —

Narrator

He didn't say when I grow up I'm going to be rich. He said it the other way. The promise came first.

Narrator

He went to Cooper Union on scholarship, dropped out. To NYU's Courant Institute, dropped out. He never finished a degree.

In nineteen seventy-four, he was twenty-one years old, with no diploma — and the Dalton School hired him to teach calculus and physics.

The headmaster who hired him was Donald Barr. A former OSS officer. The novelist Donald Barr. Author of a 1973 book called Space Relations: A Slightly Gothic Interplanetary Tale. The plot: wealthy aliens kidnap humans into sex slavery.

Donald Barr's son grew up to become William Barr — the Attorney General of the United States who would be in office the night Jeffrey Epstein died.

Narrator

Within two years, he was out of Dalton — and into Bear Stearns. A parent at a parent-teacher conference had been impressed. The parent was the CEO.

Narrator

Alan "Ace" Greenberg hired Jeffrey Epstein at Bear Stearns in nineteen seventy-six at a starting salary of two hundred thousand dollars. Ten times his teacher's salary. Greenberg liked, in his own words, "P.S.D." guys.

Narrator

Epstein was all three. He was also, by 1981, gone. The SEC was looking into share transfers and a twenty-thousand-dollar loan to a friend. He walked out with a hundred-thousand-dollar bonus.

Narrator

The patron found him on an airplane. First class, Palm Beach to LaGuardia, late nineteen-eighties. An Aon executive named Robert Meister sat between Epstein and the man who would change his life: Leslie Wexner. The billionaire who built The Limited from a five-thousand-dollar loan into Victoria's Secret.

By 1991, Wexner had handed Epstein power of attorney over his entire fortune.

In 1996, he transferred title to a thirteen-million-dollar Manhattan townhouse — the largest private residence in New York City — to Jeffrey Epstein for zero dollars.

Narrator

A sociologist would later put the relationship plainly.

Narrator

The other half of the story was born on Christmas Day, nineteen sixty-one. The youngest of nine. Her father called himself "the Captain." His one-hundred-and-eighty-foot yacht was named for her.

His mantra to his children — and to her —

Narrator

On November fifth, nineteen ninety-one, Robert Maxwell drowned off Tenerife. He left behind a six-hundred-million-dollar pension fraud and a daughter who, six weeks earlier, had been the queen of an Oxford manor — and was now down to a hundred-thousand-dollar trust and an apartment on East Seventy-Ninth Street.

Twenty days after his funeral, in a tribute at the Plaza Hotel, a pudgy man with curly hair sat beside her. His name was not yet known.

Narrator

They had both just lost their fathers. He needed a society. She needed a partner. A friend of hers — the writer Christina Oxenberg — later said it plainly.

Narrator

One was Brooklyn. The other was Headington Hill Hall. Together, for almost twenty years, they would build the most well-connected criminal enterprise in modern American history.

Narrator

The operation, by two thousand, had a shape. Ghislaine Maxwell ran the front of it. Visiting colleges, art schools, spas, handing out business cards. Inside the mansion at three-fifty-eight El Brillo Way, Epstein paid two hundred dollars per session.

The girls who came in were paid in cash. The girls who brought girls were paid in more cash. The pyramid had a top, and it had a bottom, and at the bottom, Julie Brown later wrote, were —

Narrator

Michelle Licata was sixteen years old. A cheerleader at Royal Palm Beach High School. Straight A's. In braces. A friend in her class passed her a note one afternoon, right before Christmas.

Narrator

She thought she was going to a nursing home to massage some old people. She was driven, instead, to a pink-and-green mansion on a street where the houses are hidden by hedges. Inside, on a spiral staircase, the walls were lined with photographs of naked women. The freezing-cold bedroom. The towel. The three hundred dollars on the table. The timer.

Visual restraint. We do not depict the room. The shots above carry the scene.

Narrator

She paid for that drive home for the next fifteen years. She cut herself. She installed a deadbolt on her own bedroom door. Her father called the settlement money she eventually received —

Narrator

Today she runs a small café outside of Nashville. She is the mother of a young son.

Narrator

Courtney Wild was, by fourteen, effectively homeless. Her mother — a waitress with two jobs and a drug problem — had been evicted from a six-hundred-dollar-a-month single-wide trailer outside West Palm Beach. Courtney slept in a friend's trailer in the same park.

A girl at a party recruited her. Sarah Kellen — Epstein's assistant — answered the door. For four years, Courtney brought him girls. She estimates seventy to eighty.

Narrator

By seventeen, Epstein no longer wanted her. By twenty, she had been arrested ten times. The same person, three years later, was standing in front of a federal judge — saying my name is.

Narrator

The summer of two thousand. The Mar-a-Lago spa. A sixteen-year-old named Virginia Roberts is reading an anatomy book in the locker room. Her father is the maintenance man at the club. A British woman walks up.

Narrator

She is driven that afternoon to three-fifty-eight El Brillo Way. She is met by a butler. Maxwell floats down a spiral staircase, rushes her father out of the foyer, and takes Virginia upstairs to a room with a turquoise massage table — and a naked man.

Eight months later, March ninth, two thousand and one. A small London townhouse. Virginia is seventeen. Maxwell turns to a man in the room.

Narrator

They went to a nightclub on Jermyn Street called Tramp. He danced with her for an hour. She said —

Narrator

Eighteen years later, on BBC Newsnight, the man Virginia danced with would explain to the journalist Emily Maitlis that he could not have sweat that night.

Narrator (dry)

In October twenty twenty-five, his brother stripped him of his title. He is now, on paper, Andrew Mountbatten Windsor.

Narrator

By two thousand and eight, the operation spanned:

The Manhattan townhouse — twenty-one thousand square feet, walls of glass eyeballs, a room with a chessboard of underwear-clad figurines.

The Palm Beach mansion — designed by John Volk, with a fully-equipped dentist's chair, four massage tables, gargoyles flanking the driveway.

The Zorro Ranch in New Mexico — thirty-three thousand acres, a twenty-six-thousand-square-foot hacienda, an aircraft hangar on site.

The Paris apartment on Avenue Foch.

And in the Virgin Islands — Little Saint James. Seventy acres of his own. A movie theater. A library. A Japanese bathhouse. A helicopter pad. A building local cab drivers called the Temple. And a bedroom kept at a constant fifty-four degrees.

The jet was a Gulfstream G550, tail number N-two-one-two-J-E. Two-one-two for the Manhattan area code. J-E for him. The plane had carpet-padded doors. And, according to a substitute pilot, a circular bed.

Narrator

The contact book the FBI took from his Manhattan house had fourteen phone numbers for Donald Trump. Cell, security, houseman.

It had twenty-one phone numbers for Bill Clinton. Cell, Chappaqua, every aide.

It had Bill Gates. Elon Musk. Sergey Brin. Jeff Bezos. Leon Black. Henry Kissinger. Ehud Barak. Senator George Mitchell. Governor Bill Richardson. Alan Dershowitz. Steve Bannon. Naomi Campbell. The MIT Media Lab. The Edge Foundation. Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, to which he gave six and a half million dollars.

Narrator

The case opened with a phone call. March fourteenth, two thousand and five. A stepmother in West Palm Beach, on the line with Detective Michele Pagan.

Narrator

The girl, fourteen, had been called a whore by classmates at Royal Palm Beach High School. She had hit one of them in the face. The principal had searched her purse and found three hundred-dollar bills.

Narrator

Detective Joe Recarey, of the Palm Beach Police Department. Queens-born. Yankees fan. Worked his way up from the mailroom of a state attorney's office. The case landed on his desk when Pagan transferred out.

He took it personally. He had a daughter.

Narrator

What he and Chief Mike Reiter built was, by two thousand and six, an airtight case. Surveillance. Phone records subpoenaed from Cingular Wireless and Bell South. Garbage pulls — the Palm Beach Sanitation Bureau diverted Epstein's trash into a separate truck and brought it to the police. They found notes. They found stationery embossed with Ghislaine Maxwell's name. They found phone messages from Harvey Weinstein, Donald Trump, David Copperfield.

By February of two thousand and six, they had seventeen victims willing to testify. By the time it was over, they had thirty-four.

Narrator

On October twentieth, two thousand and five, Joe Recarey served the search warrant on Epstein's Palm Beach mansion. Eight in the morning. He had a judge's signature. He had the addresses, the victims' names, the contact lists.

When he arrived, six computer hard drives had been removed. The wires were still in the wall.

Narrator

The Palm Beach State Attorney was a man named Barry Krischer. When Recarey delivered him a case with seventeen victims, the prosecutor's office made the case smaller. Then smaller again.

The lead prosecutor, Lanna Belohlavek, sent Epstein's attorneys a letter inviting them to submit physical evidence to the grand jury. They sent the victims' MySpace pages. The defense attorney was permitted to sit outside the grand jury room, watching witnesses enter.

Narrator

Only one victim was called to testify. On July twenty-sixth, two thousand and six, the state grand jury indicted Jeffrey Epstein on a single misdemeanor count. Solicitation of prostitution.

Chief Mike Reiter sent a letter to the State Attorney. He used careful language. The substance was: you have lost the right to handle this. Recuse yourself.

Narrator

Krischer did not recuse. Reiter then handed the case to the FBI.

Narrator

The federal case went to a young U.S. Attorney in the Southern District of Florida named Alex Acosta. Mentored into the role by a then-judge named Samuel Alito.

Acosta's office prepared a fifty-three-count federal indictment. It was drafted by an Assistant U.S. Attorney named Marie Villafaña. The indictment named victims as young as fourteen. It charged sex trafficking of minors.

Then, on October twelfth, two thousand and seven, Alex Acosta did something a U.S. Attorney rarely does. He drove from his office in Miami to a Marriott on Okeechobee Road in West Palm Beach. He met Epstein's defense lawyer — a Kirkland and Ellis partner named Jay Lefkowitz — for breakfast.

Narrator

Acosta agreed to a federal Non-Prosecution Agreement. Epstein would plead, in state court, to two charges — including one for a seventeen-year-old chosen specifically because she was not the fourteen-year-old. He would serve eighteen months in the county jail. Not prison. With work release.

The agreement included immunity for "any potential co-conspirators, including but not limited to" four named women. Ghislaine Maxwell was not named. The phrasing was a back door.

Narrator

The plea went forward on June thirtieth, two thousand and eight. The assigned judge — Sandra McSorley, known for rejecting plea deals — was mysteriously absent. The signature on the substitution order is illegible. The substitute judge was a softer landing.

Epstein served his time in a private wing of the Palm Beach County jail. Sheriff's deputies — in suits, not uniforms — escorted him daily to an office where he conducted business twelve hours a day, six days a week. He paid the sheriff's office over one hundred twenty-eight thousand dollars for the privilege. Visitors included Alan Dershowitz, on New Year's Day. A college friend of Bill Clinton's, nearly two dozen times. His paralegal, over a hundred.

An anonymous lawsuit filed later alleged he had sex with young women in the work-release office — while the deputies stood outside.

He was released a month early. On the day of a total solar eclipse.

Narrator

On February twenty-first, two thousand and nineteen — more than a decade after the deal was signed — a federal judge named Kenneth Marra ruled that federal prosecutors had violated the Crime Victims' Rights Act. They had concealed the agreement. They had not told the victims it existed.

Narrator

Joe Recarey did not live to see the ruling. He died of organ failure in May twenty-eighteen. Six months before Julie Brown's series ran.

He had wanted to be on camera. He had begun to tell his wife everything. The morning of publication, his widow Jennifer reached for her phone to call him. Then remembered.

Narrator

Julie K. Brown was a working reporter at the Miami Herald. The Herald, by then, was a two-story office park out by the airport, banished from the bay. Brown lived in a small apartment in Hollywood, Florida. The elevator was broken. She had a view of the Intracoastal.

She built her case file from public records and a spare bedroom.

Narrator

By October of two thousand and seventeen she had identified roughly sixty possible victims. She tried knocking on doors. She got nowhere. So she mailed letters.

Narrator

A week later, her phone rang. The voice on the line was Michelle Licata's.

Narrator

The series ran online at seven in the morning. Three stories. A twelve-minute mini-documentary. A seven-minute video of Virginia Roberts.

The headline at the top of the Herald's internal "most-read" board, that morning, was:

Narrator

Within hours, the Perversion of Justice series had passed it.

Within seven months, Alex Acosta was the Secretary of Labor of the United States, defending himself in a televised press conference. Within seven months and two days, he had resigned. Within nine months, Jeffrey Epstein was dead.

Narrator

July sixth, two thousand and nineteen. Eighty-eight degrees on the New Jersey tarmac. Around fifty FBI agents and NYPD detectives waiting at Hangar One. The Gulfstream — tail number N-two-one-two-J-E, the one with the carpet-padded doors — touched down at five-twenty in the afternoon.

The FBI didn't spook the pilot. They wanted him to taxi to the line. They wanted to arrest him before he could turn the plane around.

Hours later, on Seventy-First Street, agents broke down the door with a battering ram. The next morning the New York Post cover read —

Narrator

They found, in his safe: hundreds of photographs of partly clothed and unclothed females. Forty-eight loose diamonds, between one and two and a third carats each. Seventy thousand dollars in cash. An expired Austrian passport bearing his photograph — and a Saudi residence, under a different name.

Narrator

He was in the most restrictive unit in the Metropolitan Correctional Center. Cell block Nine South. The unit had eleven surveillance cameras. By the night of August ninth, only one was actually recording. The DVR on the other camera bank had had a motherboard failure. The hard drive on a second had broken down.

His cellmate — a man named Efrain "Stone" Reyes — had been transferred out the day before. No replacement was assigned. That was a violation of policy.

The two guards on the unit that night — Tova Noel and Michael Thomas — were supposed to do a round every thirty minutes. They didn't make a single round between roughly ten-thirty and six-thirty. They slept. They shopped online for furniture and motorcycles. They later falsified the log to say they had.

Narrator

At six-thirty the next morning, a breakfast cart arrived. They found him hanging from a noose of orange bedsheets tied to the lower bunk frame. He was sixty-six years old. He had once said, to an inmate down the hall —

Narrator

A note on the floor of the cell, in blue pen on yellow legal pad:

Narrator

The U.S. Attorney General — William Barr, son of the headmaster who had hired Jeffrey Epstein at the Dalton School forty-five years earlier — would describe it the following day as —

Narrator

A two-thousand-twenty Rasmussen poll found that fifty-two percent of Americans believed he had been murdered. A two-thousand-twenty-three DOJ Inspector General report — after reviewing more than a hundred thousand documents — concluded he had killed himself, in a jail that had effectively unlocked the door for him.

Both of those things can be true at the same time. The official cause of death is suicide. The institutional cause of death is collapse.

Narrator

July second, two thousand and twenty. Bradford, New Hampshire. Population sixteen hundred and fifty. Twenty-four FBI agents and a New Hampshire State Police gang task force at the foot of a half-mile driveway. The boulder at the entrance was carved with the word Tuckedaway. The cottage, behind it, had been bought eight months earlier through a shell company called Granite Realty LLC for one-point-oh-seven million dollars in cash.

The agents cut the gate with bolt cutters. Through a window, they saw a woman in sweatpants run from one room into another and shut the door. She had wrapped a phone in tinfoil. She had a Yorkshire terrier with her. She had aliases — Janet Marshall, Scott Marshall. Her broker remembered one detail about the property hunt.

Narrator

She came out and asked for her lawyer. The arresting officer said it was over in seconds.

Narrator

Her trial in New York lasted four weeks. Four women testified — three under pseudonyms, one, Annie Farmer, under her own name. On December twenty-ninth, two thousand and twenty-one, the jury convicted Maxwell on five of six counts. On June twenty-eighth, two thousand and twenty-two, Judge Alison Nathan sentenced her to twenty years.

In October twenty twenty-five, the United States Supreme Court declined to hear her appeal.

Two months earlier — August first, twenty twenty-five — she had been transferred out of the medium-security facility in Tallahassee, and into a minimum-security camp in Bryan, Texas. Federal Prison Camp Bryan — the kind of facility federal policy bars sex offenders from. The transfer happened one week after the Deputy Attorney General of the United States had interviewed her there for two days.

A U.S. Senator has demanded the documents on that transfer. As of when this video was made, they have not been released.

Narrator (gentle)

Virginia Roberts Giuffre died on April twenty-fifth, twenty twenty-five, at her farm in Neergabby, Western Australia. She was forty-one. Her family said she had been a lifelong victim of sexual abuse, and that the abuse had not ended in two thousand and two. She had separated from her husband the year before. She was in a custody fight over her three children.

She was the woman in the photograph with Prince Andrew. She was the woman who sued Ghislaine Maxwell for defamation — and won the discovery that, in January twenty twenty-four, unsealed documents from. She was the woman whose twenty twenty-two settlement with Prince Andrew got him stripped of his titles.

She published a memoir, posthumously, in October twenty twenty-five. It is called Nobody's Girl.

Narrator

In January twenty twenty-four, a federal judge in New York unsealed roughly nine hundred pages of court filings from the Giuffre defamation suit. The press called them, wrongly, the client list. There is no client list. The unsealed documents were court exhibits — depositions, motions, witness lists — from a defamation case between two specific parties.

On July seventh, twenty twenty-five, the United States Department of Justice issued a memo. Two pages. Unsigned. Its conclusion —

Narrator

Four and a half months later, after a public revolt in his own political base, the President of the United States — who is also the man with fourteen phone numbers in Jeffrey Epstein's contact book — signed a law.

The Epstein Files Transparency Act. It passed the House four hundred and twenty-seven to one. It passed the Senate by unanimous consent. It requires the Department of Justice to release every Epstein file, in searchable form, and to provide Congress an unredacted list of every government official named within them.

The first release dropped in December twenty twenty-five. Reporters note that significant gaps remain. The next tranche is due as this video goes out.

Narrator (over the cards)

Julie Brown is still at the Miami Herald.

Narrator

Mike Reiter is retired. He still talks to her.

Narrator

Courtney Wild lives somewhere quiet now. Michelle Licata runs her café outside Nashville. Annie Farmer is in Austin.

Narrator

Ghislaine Maxwell is in a camp in Bryan, Texas. Jeffrey Epstein, in defiance of Jewish law, was buried on a Saturday.

Narrator (final line)

The next set of files is due any week now. The shield is still there. So is the work.